From 5020ab05695b0aebd97bef4a09601321b97e4648 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: KiHoLee Date: Tue, 25 Aug 2026 22:11:43 +0900 Subject: [PATCH] Legend dictionary: UWCA (trained) in fairness figure, UWCA (oracle) in real-data figure --- experiments/make_figures.py | 2 +- fig/fig_fair.pdf | Bin 22120 -> 21246 bytes fig/fig_realdata_c.pdf | Bin 29046 -> 29026 bytes fig/fig_resorth.pdf | Bin 22245 -> 22245 bytes simulation/realdata_plot.py | 2 +- 5 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/experiments/make_figures.py b/experiments/make_figures.py index 4626c68..90ee95d 100755 --- a/experiments/make_figures.py +++ b/experiments/make_figures.py @@ -65,7 +65,7 @@ for ax, sc, ttl in zip(axs, ["HIGH", "MIX"], ["(a) HIGH", "(b) MIX"]): ax.semilogy(snr, v["lmmse_blind"]["ser"], "v-", color=C["blind"], markevery=(1, 2), label="LMMSE-blind") ax.semilogy(snr, v["noma"]["ser"], "^-.", color=C["noma"], label="NOMA-SIC") - ax.semilogy(snr, v["uwca"]["ser"], "o-", color=C["uwca"], label="UWCA (proposed)") + ax.semilogy(snr, v["uwca"]["ser"], "o-", color=C["uwca"], label="UWCA (trained)") ax.semilogy(snr, v["lmmse_genie"]["ser"], "d:", color=C["genie"], label="LMMSE-genie") ax.set_xlabel("SNR (dB)") diff --git a/fig/fig_fair.pdf b/fig/fig_fair.pdf index 5ed472162c2dfb4b4fde14a7c141b999929f7da7..2a6a6f9a29d74af96181037ef1ad98492305de33 100755 GIT binary patch delta 6489 zcmZuz1z42Z)@BG1kPc}ENfBi_NNJRAB&9_a%diRR`u5W$w1%Th#fTBkL+{bwSwp&|O=~>Z@0Q`P; zfykBju{=-ssV8Gav;>_(DBoN3D7V`y67AaJ6#DuGpmKFJ)Lc(6xnrbKV#!YuAV$oeC21OMn>uQD*Oqo0Hi0f4F_iM zu1WsBK@xg}TOjqVcjwj}ShZ|9l!Uc=>h)CBrC2bE?xX6_QOO)19<2dzyoUz+_uTmq z2~1Ch+qtbr_tr+!N4r;cT&)Q{dnJY!1xpS_SZYQ5+O%%UbZrGyAmmblc7t|_2cOb# z;^7}_1$HXVs#i5Pvz6UO-c>Z*^V@aKdbq-a@R$w3i( zHjU&rbp5=y>9YGup($sjW^1u?VVm@dG)topDSevJWVwu8Hd;uOvAVgnup=~9I80EK zWe-LPKBZ&3?ZdC61H3Iq5V)Tk8m^!wxKSnyVtcj?+i~LUV}Gz$T{->Bo^r7gI?QTt zmSvV1#}<2+4e;aL=hyXX%9PdbW~xIhWU*_^tSoCDJ(71;uPda!#;ZUcbv%SmHda~S zYznd+@BW<8*B>qQ+wc)|7nc}#!`W|KaJF0Gt74$+&ELOWoHhd)i^50c_qP`Mw#GN+ zH9crwg#i}vZY}tptF?hz%R?Y2)t65gIfu;YB%IIXJo}Cx97V#h4-?vL>v+0rmL~@E z3HKeaooU2yU*fdlzHm)OO%@U$BJVTd(!(tM+g(Fy12$k(AYYX0t_OUkoIWG^v<#*u z_nc=a?pFq3A}(1#&!Kbar|AB#Zw0v{#g0ARY~0*JEBvQeg~_)?$h;Rfp;dvln>ZFrIV?q*WM`CnawR!_7uRz7d(LNh$i6s*)dT=^IV z97~k6ej%J2OP#W{>pydA$hO|iN~z?kSYvYh)j`&bMVvZ^R#qbkbEq*%Us+?w;JxHlutBXwvYmq@32;7fJ4OpmLL^ zV8F%lI0-H0)wfTEg(cs_@kRJ-^VCp_xkhlLaV{+d(=QxM?rN5%x-L}wXmOuwS(xCP z%kQeXo`(zD+qDV)t?AjYM`Dj=tJT|2<`As$zW%l4JPNPwzgiX!&BzdCucn%v6x55X zh+*fHI$YfYF^Yq+(+4(c&s;L%R;NWQZlC(p;Ev9nf6NX1Ox76WeDah2=rpgHYecR`GW!O!MhwdCDD zHqSf%s@lwBeLiZd#oLj*a_u(3Q6*xfGb&@mRJqQM@%z2_aqchK6oz|-HKExEi6Mz)|&%VdeM1E(Jw!o@D&g}b9X=tGUor=vU~L;U;D6X_<#QY0=V zhBHRKk<}Oz;~<)c=%RvWd8ftEBo9+vF>i2U@t8(ONOVBEj?^XVqz`+eSxu(DuvTX* zoVDEi4BfjA+be@4u7aH6`xAy}cryZl?nSFO03%Gk{n~9;@y4Rn)~4WfBO7{)VC3-h zyNp5hUj58vdL0yKtaB;kBP+w+^?0d5_+5W*}2?Oy#MCKx9Mv6BmkwWR|T>h8k zzXqo3Y6Ss{ddl}5sdKH9`2D)B>bpFllOAI(+;wtcjeUB)3=BmUVJ5-PlCP-mzfe!Z zeb905N}H_>0ztzt3BF|(E01|1dc1GA%>dOtfO&aYu|{}wv8_X+RQ_!nv$dsHL0<3c z8{nI=^aJAy^M&8cL~em3ly$quTEwtSx@P#HmI1$~oY3*4c3+zIM$!4^H!ro#L&VxH zIein{=7~(G(Y7vW$=6QMo3Hbivm7YLDdfbTzO~x<4j43-dt-U^NqHCOHJh4{w~)_S z*;aIBpJ@bJHZ-}LZr4&>*es!#Uu$ z*+0GRjnT8y3%1isy6+uV5Ku+j+1NC@xX|e5yWKAsjLMQKc8mCyb=y3|dec&Mjab5f zHTcnP&^#^{4-k$E^V^UMd3*))CT#Hn>W^iq%m@CS&x8$aOlY?6pYCGI&3wK_;gLNs z6skGVBo!W8$;BizqFt*mHxZ3lz~WTCPrewf`k*{(F`ufc6A5{Q2W>EIG&^yTQbydDVPtECKfr~Hw z4zGQSI(;{`AEJm?j~4Re>$EGk8+pQcP_es#Eo7c!NLb%lGfsMPL1)=xT{8kloZYc! zbP43gqX0}F?a|Rf;;aqN@is{jiJb?HOr`RXYGqd)Rs92al(fzT{qf!pFKKpdSETak zw_Bo4mVdPQ`L_LN5p^O@qPSSIti8D44?iW@N}{H%1SVT-i>>WTL^3hgWBQ$*z%m*R z#i3nyE5Dh@-G7;7a(HEttt4|CHWNJFaV;EQbTkf3nH1^Yaw^y|y17 z7SZZWzu2bKBT{zPv0>#A-!Kb9hWEkx_!U$c+xAPf` zGGkC>+&&Q`9ss?<$-|T=ck1zs^kV#{*xTL-B5?vU20)TSSXVWP*fVDdpiR(zeq+Hh zNa^e<(PQ~Q>!VaMHBu$qwj9^;W9o7Qi}b=lpTFKWl{Z+A=Oc-{iAf;SxIMw>+^rZk zm*tv9*((bXfkYP@07T6k(rUqrGQZFJFrs3tmDE+B&}Zt7lMyJg#Mqif$!(22XEF3% zcx=ml4*l@@C!^5@fw{|h0~eRHS+VaFhAt`TF_@lmE?y?y#^9TtCwJp6_G)it9$2K^L6~G$O0c1Jblyob!b`>TX13m@$+pLyi|1h zn<%Lyh>3M%_q`iX!iD;-g_}mply@&tYOjT-dc}zNJFC9-SY#@C#;nz$Q6ca6^nQba z<(*nRV(J4ZAZusrs?FOa99`X(79VH%&%0CAriQOQNHwh*>ZZckpQCP@^e%D_1r`}l zH|s3%2_)`>b(Y7-N;w;XmC`LuO(;9~ykI7jpe$o~4AQjg8+S#5&-Aly^>cY?6H{0c z1)XRQIR8~8?PDTIgm-#s57TCv%7}F_A87$&3k&&1f2K`zPzv|r@>L#b2X67|WkD0C z#+qUhF0ku{6=sC zPYig$;nwp;p1CBpN4Tc!P>+5IWO`wq)Eq>tG~4&7IfP@S^?h7t%7fZ3)a6~xiOH*g z{PZOi@n;nbu=(MoE^FP|yTI%#khz~mlZ*X60XFU0FSZt47K>@rv+Mi;eF;T-^#QUL zZ+x^A!oM~R1S=u@qQ$yXZV6%Sb}gQpqR+=rs>|p%fVBX6*|?pZA&=PJrJT#*+co*h zLBoQ?bp-V(?2pvEe04~MTGtxM{87P+0*?-H-6a7@h1s^-5}^gO*t*(vw;0yz9i~`2 z#-E4fl~QL*-Y#pBzL5O(N~|QGU5t?;QP4<92KjW8M;$7U){%LbCP+aEtEN!*zNP~l z+(xgY9T`CL6gOcSO84&D{btS#O4A*&*SynvQ}|26&X~!s!kR5uW-CGSai$MaRj=MB z*EUpp`EM$Ym+hG}e~Ye|EK|`F7##gI)@y&UROj*65!-|AVkWG)?`F(^wM}sG=++|6 zb2P8oJx4__C68b*P*+lAT6Z`ux>>Kfv@#!ugRK6mkRCIkYJEra7eC(L5 zJ{A6|5SNRDB`uUS4xyv`I0WA2E}+@5)MptJwzw=F;jY_oM+2~F;W~5o+(&Im1Z}f@ zGIA+kyt8Bb&2&_PtvT(^`ob!&RgL+ATXh6av)_kuCmJx3{CX4RpKDFIq9%jy%gMc_ zYg8GWmxrsutlqPB3a=OYaz>5T4&OOP^&>ofDbLW)(=ci`d|#$}hJ-3xmw>>{nZ-Ggvl8JFQy+tTM1J(% z;9oLwi`(^fv-sA(zRrW+RumHLk?YD~nzx&yTAat>@ea2}0X9an4m&}_zRc@-pI&2% z7gpYvCVK^VubC)y%Ap1g*)eGq7e5Q7>sd8-LkV#!DZM$D5QmeA@$LqxyZH60FB|MP zO;h5wdY71T@Hb83Llv>ru;sYhcAN|AysQ1ON*`ZO&uhh*(FW?LxBz~fE?3d5lx$6A zE2qb$k0#f1>j!U~*{;Ue`Z2ywO0&;?Eg}C&aOYJ`AypeycXe`q&2pl3Ygul3h!b8W zv>=h!+iC40-B9oAENTDKtzEVz`V|`$k~#;npUNIZCro3Q)4O1R0gjIdNdDJ76A9N; zGv#tj+j`p)Jtr}I624ZQw6ic}FVm(ws*;BzQ5CWK4^s#{E?Ih#{dte#W$EziOBn9z zYx7OmcL)6EQ*6@RB!&wQu{Po@QsmcFqx;N<@Sp3i@~vg-Gqr>nJu zm>d+X^I zI)}8^6{e->oiR?nSRZHmn@5tDg9kmql9hoHj4pL$?dKs_NaG3W((DA#r4GV`Gza-t zi~yC%Ch%Y4B&^5`680{!mpVhd0EA%~4#GTCgU|wErvgJE1Xh`IINca+dR1W->g}|w zXpoR!>N>Xy*ZYG?<&V?O12l~4l{vx|n%~pHP|O!)Q(2}<^9CktYGag$#ct)uh1f^6 znIeXCItc|I94vVv1KAiK)jMFU%F=JsnUxw-DqCfBx&=TUUClv$GAtKReJVy0=0c`c z1uC@rF6zi{NOjBPQ2BwG2~ALTf)Rv+P|qh;>I$<05c;9)r33Jb0Kz30dnqSU3UEqI z%S>P83PBxZ_Lo?iiLwJQg26DLj1LeDMgV271ZG*!zyG~2I}JDs0s#?!Juoo%KQa^z z0TR;XMM~4;iIg~uGZ2mdf`CRq8E<oKefKz_Kwa#1o+P#7KniSCAs-Hll9QQcK%*K1nf^a$k~UyfzurA=m`@_KmdpU zxGaimiW~*8)a_lsjtO$nQhr^hCzTyk&H`OetwdM2>6 z`Y7?Igx&0Dy+VJVc|+=sc4mT9gI8K5+O{9pXQd?WUQ1e{wL`B)Miv^UsTyvP`gU(t zmqm;V)O z)942EK$~=S|87L|+Yz&zXqI#N*`a4g_j!cX%<5f!079_5aeA>oOAF*%9sEPI^hD(; zfNZKBMQ92mktW6xigP?#f_Mt@!+(JMD$B&pVU!Q{JWtMNHY2YVL&yD`N;UF$E|=UC<Muq~B8|WAojU>0u zzjY`G>;x7CJE|;s;r=I86asbX)Wlt(%^2zerEI2?NXKoAUuI36GfhJYRq1_VQ&2oMB^AaEzZa2VwH<$~Zy*l`ko z;HVQM03kppu?X-<#|Y@(*N*!y(?AFq@;Dbj2qfZoWk5)>_J2!wRCFZli1SD5pYxCi z^ojG3kC+v_X5&@GB{QEj_|7~cV;)NulX5n%Yg z@15LX2qgJyK<+pgdD1bN)hEDcI1EYPHsdGfBV**{g$0u9bo6;}1>@ocJc^UNA-{ip ZvGzXL03T-;dN7*ITY51ub$t!`{{whmxKjWC delta 7275 zcmZWrcOcdM_wOR(CWVl!YZuDh!&qPWB(i=RpT$FIEoko zu8HvUl!iyTyuI<79r8*@pkcq@Sd>QF)zy4Ud8j>@)pMu0(L1QUk=viFY;We$)M3|7 zN!{M^Ja%QaE01aH`&J2kIR~H36w+1_Zd-@25oRfO;I|$2O%A2}U{Z}ada3U>))BaX z^FiTMa7jkq3M*p|Sl-9sd1Wn}pLVXagbYYEsLdvA#NYW(&F-z;jos>*9i_3-441d< z^37jIC%yZQM}2LCCFT;N$N0l+enqZSJp0O4AS!R;*mE7Zoo7@J;R{Ua-6)S*w99%0L2oMl0Si%&FBq3n$t-5}C92C~>o9)jQ{pjpvg3 zhkH$Cwk9W4Bf9jSu%*zfH$=rB#&V^6M4c zRHh>Br|%&T>z1$aP+lH}z(^=kH~>7@UINVvTX zDZla6w^7da^9{rI*q-&Tq9SpHo~9-HTUM3`dmwp_c}#oN7o?;w*|9Z5d8t@CMnD-bjubNzl6 zXMQAE()PaFob|AT*U0ulD__hxOGN>FtRJqBNdshl{L^BQh5^K~MboZeAj=ixI3RBb zK;*y`xYC8n6UeBX1TPj>a^#$ID(vdM-ej7f}V@} zHpR}vFUyy&jJIBttvm=d40r{T1$I5#+9M6xw5UAp5n9l%vO9DX*>yDNY~Cw$zHt{P zF#Ykkw00NvUh>epS>tJ3vt(q0DHF{y7JZ(-^m}JYxFh+MXtUcp^UzFRv`XZ>=E@u19gGyeIOs+ntrOm4DZ(UIqd z@z2f5+Hqn}BrZgSrfdxSY8n(yQM(>|gp1vPxV^kLsRvwQn#2lS_xN%ko3MX#O{?vv z(wY``)n;uZJo>^EVVN&4@bVbHsC0SJQ%?fs>nEOS=bAAR*%ki2+#Wt2#n?#+5Lx>w z-DK?)Y5Sz8Ikq|?izf<})kh0Hr@_5>! zlog`}k|Ca@!^GHo{mquP#!3Re}sKe?Da=qz3Lx?e+Gh;w5 zhgjt)4-t*0ocQeAM$YbY9i(>xa9fmC>C@7kPG}h5nJYhyL}J{cX8maOXId0_d1|mP zjk%t2ga0(6FPRLb+H`6H7A&v<;}@ZA@mZG%tyzjWasw$AUTjsE;T&sH9 z)lGzL$SDtxj>o6xTCz{mi9F{kl4YG<6ls5vu=;4OlEloI&c)<@Uyfk?D^sR25%vh? z7yXapK3F{0i@ToE?X~t~9as3sOO=;)Ml3c=db3kwX!z63M?b)?>0~(^9h{jAW|F)2 z1Y|>c6WSNZe2Owb#VyDm(ydEWT&ek4FbfKoK1_>!)1&WOr~yiE zV?4*SAu`+IowGd9akI?~YbpB-BtO%`Ops}bZ0%vnBF%FT{SnWfjpLnP47o(#o6-}} z`9Kx>K(&H&T0sAoNTJ2bQi^V`|I)YB0`YK1S)GSHm%j`wzd2XASpIBMXa4f{^qHuP zz~@Rlq_?@KmcH+tW5$m=UL4SK1diz3KEE~sm&vTk2eOmWCiAMxh)$9AD;AYfMASD4 zK98(mpy3!(@>UT2nre^x;UfQYy=UV7H;}V{ODAWxPqpC8g{Pvr0L#vg2R?{H;WR_- z#ox}WOfIWNVL_F zA!qvrB9*t z9WY|-o9b-Koz_(gClKdr*&Vi>`1w0LX4L@>qLdsvFXn-GQYu$cuS`BdHsI(8mGF4A z`nACd*{c_tNBjj!t+?sLFHNC$OVL9C`FZPN?TEKmvoBlpNf4%Igv`|d7z_|~t$q^J!gYN2C0+kj93k(Z1JgBr7DmkWuZGK-jY4)WQ zQc=XVJ0q5Wk(^bpIGac7D}nuB*>_ufzOEK432zizyngr%IBgW#j1v}C1B0JFvfNC( z{24-q9~?cNKvO8bw%32~G99+sTZ@lOS3b(72mX);`G(9J*u=KCP{SC=4$bs75eI#fk zAns!itgeG2Z{Dzs?WcZiBf)X@6y1LL$YcAOY9=gZdi+yF zv>?4o2RG}}%mPzGl8DEFy(vrO!+u^%@jpeY3!P|yF;35Sz3&avzypkG_9d?OlL}?$ z+^;%+o(!IFX}@DySuO5q&omDwx1If4TbdT~+%{)HY!?kyb4_OdQ1_uTI@>0Fc>H1S zz^sTrtWy}rtNUDuVjy45e)55q&Mk9Ai$@FK60_^0A$aZ~)On9uDw~ubL6|s+uH;aV zGJNH-RX1TMr83dIMM@EG*146_Fi>FbVc7a8YkSdRvGhFgE3*UWi++1h>MnBkgOh^z zbIJMvFG-|pIHD`*v4iUaPrVc!3`+!wTnXNHA(8}_thljJ+QFGMq~;&HQ=KH^xyN3( zAwfp&@+-L@2@6e^?OZECMF{EWBFy7*w`ii-H%zMuGJ~X5MtK|GBWR7=bX=xb*MFB+ z2vnH898t^jtQ%bUVxM94UZSvurT((Oe=Q)B5pd z#>BvLmp*n)syMIFXMN-tx4UaI&T7xg$Dt5k2d}NVW|3~6jsZzMXV;~s)v==Ar4D(E zZ&H9BHo2;|b#~gm>24h_a#DR59P6Pk=)7|N0#4_i#tU-y=6)rP2(}*1%Gy+Nx)^bx zc5(v>7;O|%Svu4Y(c;0z-?p@2pcc5e%ol8}g3F{j-*1}YzayU*r*6yGP}ZJg=RNtQ z-fiTUkzz?vz+sOIF6^~a%^cA#NAC|s=TV2`4+ zdMIshON+_RQ|k8QlBIH&1nZX~XByukKIhu@pCdXQ16^2qYnracBo$}wU!Nbbj%ixO z?5D$vofdO^E3(R$Euc9PcIbgb9Em?RaH_bX}B=nt| zksDggHY-YKyZgs`(};J^6BW{i97}=@&F$H+*cb0K=SY1L&o^@S0}&G@mzm`I1-w^r zmizAg+wM@Y?^PaKRtg_|ptkQ+K5?&vI8=>^IBL5Oc4SYQJIrzA${msMD0wrRy>9p8 z_HwvWA8yZJUMT~5vYqK!mQyicyf_qoHn3qICb?7OCwlKj}<{6H03 z7l(tOc0T*Fp_(zHZ+S1j7^x<`kI{TUfivb`Eh81VYCa^cRI&q5U?SWz90$8pbT_#+ zA0=O}HcYd&9ID zUvH!DO&!+MD2-gMGwM9(IFvU#wD9GH(tR8kzgSuA+0A}mJbqOI{?y@lP}qC6Ymn~T z9cLEFk`~eE<8ShN>uGY`^8!OLEb+lzO(D?rVC5OM%?y*qBEg?K(N^AG)*Msgz`K$i z@`$p%V<_{U#SYFu`8P$s?ffy&+#WAZdyNDJBk0riGm}6ec+MN#IB~UVJ6QR;~(GR#;HUo*^o(7%j~!U4bw9Y-BR*CMK-k`RY4{^P0K)meS zvnJTu{N}f3dYtXFy+0Yp1!wBZX;mbdQSU;NCL?ckbM`vp|MONL_$e+SZr6LdhUvG_ z45%fB^ht0I`9-nuT|3{BwRyvhC0N^X{TE~G*Hjr-;W*N+z)~DVyEot1;PtJR3`M@l z){r~Xg1Jr-De@~MY;+J5R});)c zJ%dJ#{4n2ox~Z(4wsi3vb1&EXtjds-T@j|V=@%$i*j<);N%>!yW970H!~pzf&NMk^x+qkDgo<>uiVTa@Wtiec{dCNmCIOV1c{W4&RcurlG`8s zxXPR~`6l%9?{DI>UfxF}%I4m|_;oNp!SR+o0G|M*$Nv(>;zwZg_!1UAf&}Cq0D#2z zfUXeUKm`E+6j7untiWyn$kmk<<>jUEtO(uzipi2jgh2!Va7ow!Bge~Pb^N>mR2sr)BkpI0wE!P zOU@u9^dHIEorvHc+0n$*9E60QXh2~XD<^ZJhWP6pv#^Vs0|@yK22XP*qVhKge1;h4 zuYonx5|0=IQ%@WT!i}B>FyD)%uLrB|GF}>DbafE0cN7u;J4RiUV_si-i7n7emr z^n#~7`qM6SA5plD9gYpjaw@9ucNh~FD(>{w_j#NjZ5S6H)i^J*CWi?X?we)Y6Y;EI zFwAR9^VWBOi1qjBRj2GJWkd_qQG7AkV!~~0B9%iDR}YT=qqnW0(X-Q5CfGLZI$77D zr<-#{G9uRJ{_O0YUHmb|SNw@?%vYIf)+0hw+aA;4g9}V-v>GKM3&~3twznmZ92Lzi z7KNv)CXj#%RWt8iM+!1(hwYE@D4x^sQ7BL>P`#7apKYdIY|@W& z6=0Og){1%4bPo0O>a`35bq^7MtjNUzbA{UauVnx~1ye_^jvJWWYj7JUXMk*&i(NN^ z^pzi@=^D=M+KZ#C8COH?3bQFe(3tDP!*iBomzg~}z5>WJ3^G*H*A3(uA@OX|`Eu8V zy1$k1`n96(y!NhU^m^xU10efa$h?PM4DdouZF_r-`K!9)K$_l%aT#Nd`OW!tN9Ur2 zE?mpUmHdXaOXUsYEPt#SGlz#ZKokt0DB(wf0^?aF4FMRurzBB<;14Agc>bZ6wu6qn zwW))dISBPPZzLp6jyVZNV(?Z{9hXiVPt0#B-P3kLpy9BS&G08^1RDLvc{t*02r=Q)2ZG^n^xp{o z2M`QL!v6?9IU0^RlN}fVJsXRF!%z1Zj6fl9r^x_DU?684k>InzNFtR^Wd}yW&NLc~ zB$nok9|}cWx+f3rUuJ?)XZs08!O^E%0!E>T-+;e@|6eTnEEqHxewrU(G#v70RZr@V zMxE&$7z2i#3C6$>XD-GdPp0+c`5zbz@s?9I2p9_gC*yzpAYd2@i96$nfS$etLagB# zauJJl`eFzK3_smY2n2SPtPuFWB*gu@7$C%YodyF1pQ#K43Oz$Y2+?!~G!%VyJc++w zrvT!>M1Ut>=RZnF+;3<10{kpLASlFHfG8OBG=U*V%)c4`n=lH20E0wNU5rAY&y*U8 zKKW_*10Zp=q9OPQ|; M19^Gn)Z~Hx2jV6y82|tP diff --git a/fig/fig_realdata_c.pdf b/fig/fig_realdata_c.pdf index 243ff3a4781f9edb4fa6d974be1b634ed7495f85..a97b65dae7d639cfc8213529ef75852dbfdf74fa 100755 GIT binary patch delta 7328 zcmZuzWmr^;)&?mhq(ekeQE8bD5KyF~yIT;YMRFL}h=3eg=~O@^q`Om6N>ZAkLl_XG zzZSI(>BbU1oizqv}^VlT}Gu)R1k|GK$~BMS!AUaOXSaorRPJ$>AA z2jH{*y{RZCD0b@3b^@zDy4ZRaXnJJMCP_)kw!CD(^jBnS8Od`dipx2MTM4ys1A#qy z%5oX@cC?2s)f)jvNCqpg4FKH=h@#p*az9%CvRO83+#18Fx)ar++|R%jDSQHwC?KLH z$%A-7?$NmHhvYiF*!#UxEGr&neH_Ax(`AztqUt0=EgcCxUGU3WM#-E*m@Z(#+^ z@Tgq4`NMfY?}AiQ3M4FV>M|z)u0FaFdU2K&VDEcxj71;WVaa=1#e-Gmfh0Gn&iKB?AuojRSB|*PrWV=8uA&fT{IpfkB0 zwvSSusqQ?0LhDA}?O}Z-9-0pRUY6m06-~LQK9sp{*VLEWaji+3iT<{ycEXDK*mfWG zbY}%CK5o`;7&V5tGv9bC{zDzfPBB==BTSX)VSLIB$JaYJ*V!WDbWHO7t)DSHt*q(F z@5_|c_y;*I^|UaRbc`;XSk?hM09FTkYLT}xdqjl$yf%w}FV1-ix{vb?pPlsy0=>TH z>1tEsdMPAA_*LqcmLL*hst|Z!0UiCLfwfPJ!n-k_XqWynb-{2rS}{dL8CLCh2nN-3 zMA*i#3+b~m(&RELzCB9n;^z!?PohetZ|$f~->K?aP3q{brV7#Sv{q#^1n4*hCr7Gx z8e(I@H{bBQVUzeVJi+WW!{owBI><(J92Cn#=n)THKTEQi_=#PYqU$pz{3`mTM6de?l0|2PTnrt+279K zj8;CeKGa*q&F=QRIT@=1%IuZp@vc2GsTVGfYc1!oSRZl5Y^_Z@axT=D}Li_fb_Nu-I1sgm&YPvWZQ(=)pCyCso4+IrP z$jwa|(Q>x-95#qnpVWpy=gdfWZqJT26vxgKZ|FXx%B@h)6!J|3DA<|!LT!@!`6UF` z`yvCPtYia6x>aIJGQW?T73g*C^fz48q;$)DF|uwTY2BZub*odiP_&q+QejyfzKVDJb=S$F3n#+M&D%cc zeqvl=lXcfx|K2Yszy=(YrSVt@g>f}dWu<0RjOFGtGpCqHP8*u?^5iO!7Vv*-4q(ek z-KS|}4!yVS>Jvun z#$K`U;>QSV;lay{lIy9?HaBnngN!I0ya^s9~j__`E=p^VP^g2#J^VHB-in+gF}x z+ETPJsuYbpka8o|VBir5n34a$AWxs$A6i4grz%M7uc*jLc853AwB^ih3Wi+LlZXNZ zN`4~WyPV})!XsHOlp?oe>pHv;*R0zdm~mZsG~cu&2v~h#z{r`K-RM*-q$x(tRVfy1 z^x!5bsYJ<-m}rT+OjfO*EamkWwSy(Vd7@)|9q5=_Wg+`^%K7mcL<3h3y2yOKH~4xQ z$5X1^ac)Z*qG1Wvd(7V~SPACx$?h!a6RcDO?W)U`M0lA*vc^Tvl~T}(To#ihn$uGd z3_yiEiUblpl;pP;-%}4aTvkC1hu#^Y4~)N%ogZq%XQF9nnp9526`NgPhi1RhoqwH- zk0Hke_f@Ae%Reu_TSI}@Cd4_~$EaZK#3LKZN|n7S(M=V;;%Oj-?5dgW@}DB zns(`D6M-3}%4DCCd`%O5#RemtHWN`Y`8l7T5pjS>nXI%be=e=eN0kBa-CY+uRi4i` zRkiI@1wJ@C+T&T88`+~)I|TQ69DWT=wnFnYoMM~WS||F_-(2f2ac82HW+-WjdtJ73 z6@Ei|zoURZ_>RE8pkw|_Ee|*qK7gd{l1!XqT^v{rh@nVuU!9j_-Ql9o}8B{qxXWA`d5K88DlI| z=LIo$2WS`VPEK|UfAzYbE9<%qB<_nrQJTRanepKa$V+d0b6#c?AqZ8^93WACUVmR4 zWwDf_*G|tva|O*6KGbpcUVar2_>2xSoEY*VybJUI^eeT1CGoZ~ts&Gga*4TT?ZT%l zX*-Qjg5FaKq zDY|Z+8l>fw#FQQO#{Chx)>zh6QGt;kR2Rsio`RUSn47OY?g|G-$ghdZX*ji^-gYZ5 z`lL^;`0XIS?TnT+HSauKnicHCoy?DgI)qnM>{LBp4KFJUulw{&ei}Q1`z8_v7?-F3 z78DlFk((oyJzF0ym<6-ky)Sl{QKy?iL4`A2H13-;!=`vHPt|&gQ~TGnjBgrm(6}St z33G0*0m;cF)pTR7WU8B@+SJh9G}q>y&mQS*(;CS&iwV53347y)k6sRMRxYG8qJE&M z<{@mGKTe+FvTKhUNNxsQo@;Id3Z8It-ZE@4obnQ?4d2;}QaZM%(%T~1&I(0xg_h@6 z1brUZ_$hT5m7p$Zv}MdDC~hpi%pLS%O-EIX=@9ef?mkRQVX=_rq|OWYRxl zN`bY4&b;$2(ZSjkZ!gIAtb9IQ_FP@yuM8JFy9qO&gWO!SLqo}dev#)ckccl#(LQKh zZ0cyw8?&{eSVw+a>~?Lc35%)Dx!+K2{OrTaCmT{4@8emOekKUL&t{b~$*j_|SWVbE z7+`}k(5W=O`cm?RiJCYJ4C3;A%j!(iko%PViOMULsA>~*&Bds!LF|azPkTNTd{Izx zpzV5Mu@(6PZ|rvx!S&H~PQbsmOe=Ov+V1DnHzmAtVM76!S>>i{q)wZeDpS4AGe3sF zM(4rT!MTGRx}Ns9J`clPy9m>891}b=Qd^;a1tyL(>E4=G)faYILs;JN30sd$?bhKf4PS*j~n~235C1n$5f{CtKl3H4Uy1aqROA znKoi~p4VF&8?O3~#AR;ZWQ_$_sys`os5~GT?M!&Df)*dIkQVjG# z3Yz(qW8`_Jt*!veA6nGA`y+e_@8)T{KG;GUM#UAc_rPB>1OYFLAV7Z=W zGcQ0CColP~amV*leoB05>>8ytcp z-$RXciKA>N8;HKY*p9D^iy(@Y6pMW`<)3ek9gBF2N+-3wXnpf3DUnTjsAyN>0FPzu zL$;nm?Aa#_k8shg&hcf%E*rsY+Wb?WMUw$R(+z3bsBnE)TAW;E0izdeu6F8pH^0$# zj{V7pT3_3c#v2XAlC}tI+1Wyu4>_v&L!IjSCZ*DE5kO^3cuol^|06>QL_&!kRh&~m zj%qzai2T)7*(r z;Bee3&ts2Yp&N>8t;~#1bnIgc)7RkV&2*%j>a#XuDG-J_uO-7$ZM&kEA#>&SwB~so-WbBK5oZdzahkosYneQb&(C z>Q$P4n=e^|wEZ8ADeMLL=!r4ohWnx(H>MQ2wOHD=Lqt{Y#XVaL9la1d)~FHtl??jD zT$_ywxWTTnKtKNBN-*6>zokcGFHd=Bve5*qRxc$F`u47$=rOm%khPbyHKOU*bq=#j zMmHe^W@8c8F^4VvwybxNCZS@v-hab=MXXC8Fw78y)lzC%?bm`0q(-~!Xl z!uX5tj&J6!pG<9cQMEbg-D7ldVu^j{?Uh(%QL|??e1PenC|u7Ruh7@x`{@c*Fu7*y zMfsAwm~l4#avyxkR%uML!d8idUjxto*hAXGjX_`UU2e}%e(t`P{(9E7t-e*a2VNfF zdqvw&8EVwly;!WiH8C`yy__)Q+=*&FWXT?+ZLExm_Ak?p@yD^Ou4j!Gr61v@8)m-kas&|pBUm;t<{?#Q%wIvP+bcBlKBo(9& zJ4M$f6uwkUPtLA+G@?6lmGiH{G-VsW0lx&VX~2K_Y0#gU)KJDNV*Pq-R>fueIgOHN z&1Yl%^?&~1evMag(IQWmN&UHWb_PW-U1s3Ah_iH-_8Ybxp}Ev2vXMz|KznH_E-Vp{ zr@k?ty6D%*UhthD2S2`Q$@-qrjO9D!HjuF3Gk8MkSBN-rx@00O<*Zl;1kflpcnG{D zqv@xgP)(W7ecD_&WOQehMxnt&DB2kV`GGf)T5;n3o;%Jg`1(Mp#9P6YLD#VNLlk~9 zdnCfuOgES=$O88z5qB^$Q0_3)nz17v&2;PN~8#l@Y#Z;4g-HcX?xby3*{B|L0cjU11&`sXx z)T9?Jq?=53_@%~%rd!l|lMr9yZ;94i_T!{Erj;1eeZ`3mf*2A3=HT|18;|-l&1k%Y zaMx{Ht0jQDx}|D${M-7VvW`#u+wxtPlhUT@rB>LF+Xpj#pvbBA0ClA$b>rVEA2d#P6}_HVYv$${aS=FoSL?TyYa+g@OE?EE-->#|oC;o!Le= zk!X_rUG|E^Hxw;ep?Na*WK>P;;hi3Hj^+gcnMzYL<0G=tL**1U~#mXx-(Hhq*7H@+_?a9Bg`)L_l3wD(xaoPRV z!fNy?k6E(%`b0>zvdCc)kJAOB;I}tD6SNF3$daACw-!1B^d-9r{ zqH0SCA!7u}#yHmvj`ul3ObE$0Du$fQ7-T?_T#miS5eL%qJklF85PO{C1!cH#cP z48jGy3M3fTW$iLYkM%mG-75RQ?R$vEUlao`J&q2bF6E-`=>}KLxMQZPwmghD+pgR& zx{90?y(lR5zC@_dgZ9>)K*V=jy&c!s~1(!;^4+<=5%^z zL^cb@1t_YhgT+ye3<83~5fKlcD*+Jr4bb1u4Z9nZ|NMYJ(J<(F8w>U@V_&{^N-=m&$K@bmi!2A#>4 zzz=~Sw4veWbpi%M;Qx&H4F7-V2ZPTPbv_{&g(67!_mMd72Z4akYv!y5`n+ht5H#q| zG5y0o7z!cSaWE7LBj_56Ah;r6D4O7kfY0s&K`aajBVZMV2EYVJ;2;03<3@%=o*0}I4)oWijZm~m_Wc_BpmW5{r~JA z7>Pg<%n5b2cjpnKz=R_~K?z5KLK5l&4MGwyjfR2&0&$^XsQ>ElY{|fA1p2%m1PUiS zr%)*5{7B9gmf)D3#r{kEAdumI)DM9o2wz)gsy@#G1cE>jyaOO8Fo6w$L`B?w@%R!9 NMtSFsl(IDC{{c8aIS&8; delta 7353 zcmZWsbzD^K)|C#620FOY%!nNoH(;=dkB3l zdnNCW#iyEL=m-IA84<4bGQMdszof*;q_N4^7rUaOcRL5P1sDd1;LMZDpt@-BixUvw ze0H#u>~{Zr9o6__AZtYY8rlOp^Sg_DzMLaiJOu3lo%`LjP56*$`i4#hIuu+Jd%-zR z14Ndd{N}D;NWQp#4Pe&s@SR7A2ZKGJ*Vsu2gYE2uf}}gE#Y8|LJRmEn6+opq=y&fMv_(y?LHTWAw{Pdc(cjJD&5QjgCYi;2KYA zSuYy$`hrixG`!3=BAwmN9De_PH@hfoCCya(dm!xa&s^^8(LBsa>|FoP+`z1O4UGMFMSLP{0GBMnwb;NOrvUi>9B47z5PYai{KkRg155hNT2S&Cck`ZMtZ}W2SPk0! zq{{uHR`##QPDt)twc)Zu@zdS0JwSiwOuhPZ=pK=8d|9Zj7=UBr)Ih=3+DgKxPx@kf z^RH@@Z_A?ui9Y(BIqA9w2Jc@ANH&4RK)1q zzo9bsYU8DgkEx6*Ct!Tg;r~fz$@_Ivk;+z}N4ZNi?O3)W+fI;+Amyj4-oU4EZ0?8{ z(*cbN#lds_XvsP0TJ`F|clWa$@9h-3P^6`hdJ;c#H$E7?DO)Yq%;D>H$LCGvbpDi% zVb+vi6aQ)?@0Aqlzj({H-aK1g)22OZmo`=*A^ z47JvlPu5$9O)pu7>RQO3)RIl{f2HtiEa!MH9#RXcZfo;v`G;jAwHYWS?Px)%GO?)ZRf9+KvT(7?$$3Zj_ z*B(SAq%S>1`h{STtk+PKQ-HVtLAqA~dpUR{sFc)i6PooX|6|T+jUjIy;ak?h+8G1% z{rAs*qc_arY*R2pN;kumqKnq|?7=Ki;h}t(=T=VAtQbcp2UZ;bTg8|c<|1nAc+YD8hLz(+{eIY zLk^zzF(x0cKlNn{kt6gYQFdGT+@#{W_SInPcI4-%D~;TlJ>DPbTEX)fpJ?`{oyAQYaZfWp|biP@bw^$iy3|Sc$2_oYP9G~s1 z*FJsE9Hv}jvko<&V6<6sGiHyHp*#FyJGTj}pA?rBx5v>$S;mfW9~K-y|Id^))^4b*ZS&9J{sstwu zC*hhqdEY!~U&XC$%S=IEoVSnG%&_Zg-BZ=~7d|fm+?8z~MexPu#4Xp}|KlmG6vxbc z!b9f4bwj1F(!0e}@ou5}&f@-DfXt{T{T@lhC_FfmGcIyp`2B$&BVBBo6X3tEwZb=Esg z^V)ybfIkftqs&Y0b1Q*lchO9uX{(Yv;omzDq8+8W+oi%c_Ocf5=z64^4?sC0LBHYV;4WT!Y*D=!RUa@@J8T&l#f>X1PZBJT6 zJn?GM!(7H?%c%YFfm!zIdnZm;ZNCA>1w^+OEDFvn#zhwL1r{vtX^|%gW8IvycGsd- z3xV~Nyb!3^>AG{$Q;Fcd2H#d=&;g2nU+>=i^>z7i(_rD==);Yb(>LICu3sS+-sWwU zv4dkNSr^VO!@Cd6rs<@cj~+uhM?n;kJQCM_?CUSOa$EITE8!Vg`Mgq-TX0KWf9#l$!skaRk9>7tLseVQhQAb#o{e2bc1L2 zrO^Ju53+qfDvgeUXJallQw_`p+;oI;Xsc2O4j;A|2&qvTWVfbJkhs8z*+9ulDY7aH zQ%xS3GvxN@eh7*rq0Kp#8ev1slMTc<)3NFXOT4QrGYw7!<Djsl6w6o&O zyu!B-LUUC|Ac&CZYPQk?ZoJd%JfpEs`K!pxxL~HI&wyyly#Dmzm1{J5*I}-d_Qf{VBDtK)ZH~F&jxrXx;kHt|7OYN+)(y98 z&hHK0n`!=iALPtFt!qc@$_^ZLgn)H7Cgo{ne3Z=Q?)~nR#qOR3P13LY3{n$Zb{yfF zQK%;q^>R2+(Q|S|fUlumJL)c!InbwhPQOUAGZ-RM7aT2U6Z_+R(`B5OB}?Rex07R( z`|~K-imeyQ!lWAIRixNIu6Z<6E?S}nx}|+@PBtHenL=06H>y>_GHQUG4?z!>1L-$k z+>tHZc9oYZXiry|#Wu6?`~94c2<#o;OE~EW5i6U}7O;83ok&-sE>!#!Evhn0E?U%3 zntPx@yodcEThP8vU!y89C+{cz;9k4by##;%T6UHb1iN*0Ow3d{5iLW3bJ2ueFK1_< z;mcH-ej&HLmR^b7jp=KEnF?LiBWnJpA?+80>OUTnA->rrC4J@AD8_OaX12&ssa7d9 zcyn);%2D48c^)GTb48~X4h8+y{Okssf?w7KO%7w*t`{d+^eWl5{gfJ?M$p!X%KHY& zO!2X^DMy}^b{nCYJck((seo6x`vh&z*=e-PS_S;B579N7MQgr;0P22kgDNGVXkV&s zaQby4K1~Qc`Ou**6>X1#W_k*0JM*H5aHCdd>euU6LywkpeDcOg5>uyaA z#(=u^rdKxYT6eAwe$&}@!eeUk>$n?OAdozuakarQ#w+L%#0CkO(}qxv&?p!nZ&fqrrfV* zn77~PsQ;CzV10*Dv{1ZZ{;&#nV(T!k-pYIV&@Nf1E77dO4ed&6$MZN2>Lz5JY@T;Y zMybKD;GBN<7&jPn=L2WX@CyrG&D^=L_*VD6UTOa?-BzPd`W7PIB{@y7Ydv}t>GL~E znYJWg=+?IB(NhkduS5)to*JUWS1<>*Y4kkK- zWX2)hh7+qF80#^2-dm5iI@W8N=o3WxzQ1tZ%0b}uYS@}wyR2V`J zzTqsgM#Y`e`I#PSH{3q%7p%Au!8K`qeR#q|?Q4d8@u2`Av3e_aM+iZjh;|&$3W1uo zcL_{!xQm=ps$)xWnUh5Gi}~UqCHpW-rlz`DE-30z?PgW!XKCVPYsbZ-buYJ)7Hv(| zT!}-C3d8Co0Ba%-wt%VX(=c|@=CfCQx$w1UOsP>6xp3z{fhfoU4?&na8T1-X8gsU zr!Rxc;S>;fYrk-6U%}sBZl7JTSuOmTSd4f>#Dxv3JD{*oSz0OFk1Ab@aSl4#aLonz zItcr{EmxOnw0h^@D6{!`q&UA>^sf?@K9MLjTW1e!0>7A3TZou>!h71LOxRRnSmKY} zr+c2Rqy!>2i^jg_pD%@yjP+#=!49|M6b2ln914K;!SFIiRxH2!Jcp#iKJFsCQO$S2MpM+ka%gXi=xF8xiZG^81FNafX!(C+;8IJ?Jwc;C+ni zW(sxnvy^hM%h;CnUcc|#03s~8WU(a%JpMFst`PsZwQ+1tc)S|`7Q+I9WRG2VSOHqOGAFJOQt3O+b1$CW* zh|5ZBJQmhB?COs>Tvd{=;+)U9hP$`8CO&P%s81!!MCBW7cbp2wXcG-a9?5qB1c|P- zUhf7=k9eMadfCV%Fp+E{nH*=GKdH+bA2C5T(Pul|oQcY|jh-GQp1Ad0vyywlAWEeq zy`5|1yZf&?-=r&@T^Goh3h;37v%&5t*N+v80T6871|<2kp47GsMW;|%Ji)4Y|0t0P z7G>#kt9ayE8evy%L#83a%g546fMvbx-Xz(TO@aIBay2UvcQ!>wXoADdXQGmR=rqx3 zDQ->KVuXEFZ}RsnYVj$XC-u7ujie<-4)OOq>6AFHK78KYNMx|KI^rrMtE^|4-|O15 z*p@`AT3Op%QQ{Sxr+@Pk;f*=V1*l~Jb~s7ec;k`Xig{L_h;db-JCVPIJdMF%(5 zE5*cF{AgLHOB!usF|2K)puR#)Ft7N40svTv ztC%bu%uxn!SC23JC+Y;>oM~CozSsArBt=%QP&8f)iU8xsP!RkWCVb`%HaypqCS1^j0f0jBPQc+P zyciOK#EYTOcxd4m1YSJ^6oSV90Ym@)IpDvjA`l2XxCj&kk17I#!dwP}guwC6Az=_a zB1kwI{@=Ob?xtio4F4-S7>R^mrVB4Ad6{}&(t21CIpJa$kp0)4p&6xaK5 z6DS0Nx~vQo7rLAaM#JHk=LSaOWB@M9kH*097-OLL$rw1E1Hrg;!E21cATHN~fFa<& z&jEig8w3o+ONM}9sLM8ofDy3EOdvQj;Kwki%Ra&l33bUc02l&6{%arpvknjl28>q_ zHzzzWP$=wDK`;c0g#7P}!MGR(dU;F`7!gCX%y!;pAa2?U10T=oJ4 z4#(RZoCT48OZ{)9;TYJzi2(n)>mUf+l3nrw1OWx(u|vRM_~(#FJjMu|kuKLmLhvpR z0D^@52hHDLkO%}GY9tCT8G^*%OO3+maJexG0mqXcg~Z@M|5N|}$d3l&n+6TR9|;